Most Philadelphia area residents spend some part of their summer at the Jersey shore. For many that means South Jersey in towns like Sea Isle, Ocean City, Avalon and Stone Harbor. (Atlantic City deliberately excluded because there are acceptable restaurant options.) For my family, the Jersey shore is Central Jersey, in Seaside Park.
Regardless of which area you call “The Jersey Shore,” there is one reality……..the food sucks! Sure, there may be decent pizza, and perhaps a good dish here and there, but lets analyze this situation for a minute……..
If I am not mistaken, the Jersey Shore is on the Atlantic Ocean. The last time I checked, the Atlantic Ocean was rich with many species of fish and seafood, yet there isn’t a decent seafood restaurant, at least that I have found, at the beach.
Let me be clear, can you get a lobster, shrimp or clam dish at the Jersey Shore? Of course. Are there any dishes that are good? Sure. Are the ‘”good” dishes worth about $14 priced at $35? YES! In addition to most restaurants having mediocre food at high prices, most of the starters and such do not create a cohesive dining experience. Do you generally crave heavily breaded chicken wings along with lake trout in a buerre blanc? Unlikely.
The problem I have each and every year are expectations, which are too high. Every summer I start a journey looking for the one restaurant that must have something decent to offer. Every year I am disappointed. This year was no exception.
Seaside Park is a sleepy little town adjacent to Seaside Heights, AKA “The Jersey Shore.” I’m not exactly sure why, but businesses struggle here. There are 2 restaurants that are generally successful through the summer season; Ebby’s and Bum Rogers.
When Ebby’s first opened about 20 years ago, it was the first really great restaurant in the area. The Italian cuisine was delicious, reasonable and the service was friendly and sincere. Like many successful businesses, the owners sold out and in the past decade the restaurant has changed hands multiple times. It is now average, but the quality to value ratio, along with the service, is 20% of what it once was, when it first opened. Poor service, dirty wine glasses, mediocre food and a $300 bill made a dinner last summer, our last here.
Bum Rogers was never the greatest restaurant in the world, however, they used to have a fabulous happy hour with a center bar raw bar that made you feel like you were at the beach. Not only do they no longer have the raw bar, the quality of the food, seasonal service and deteriorating interior make for a depressing experience. None the less, we ended up here last night after we walked out of one of our favorite bar/restaurants.
So it goes…….
Like most families, the economy has dictated that we are more conscious of our spending, so I made a decision that we would only have one “nice” dinner out this week at the beach. Obsessed with dining, I spent all week trying to decide where we would have this meal. The idea of eating on the water is highly appealing to me, however there are limited options. The Atlantic Grill in Seaside Park is actually a very nice restaurant and arguably the best restaurant in the area, however, I calculated that dinner would be a minimum of $400 without drinks and that was for 4 children and 2 adults. (Our children eat as well as we do.)
I was interested in trying somewhere new in Lavallette. I have never been to Rockefeller’s, so that was a consideration, except that they appear nowhere online so not only could I not call them, I had no valid information. SCRATCHED. My next thought was a place where my sister had her rehearsal dinner on the water. They have since changed their name, so they were difficult to find. We did manage to stumble upon the place and the new name is Catherine’s by the Ocean. Their ocean dining was perfect, had it not rained every night. They do have a dreary dining room, but I wasn’t willing to eat in a shoebox at the beach with entrees priced on average at $29.00.
Since we are buried in Mets country here, we have been dying to catch a Phillies game. Since the weather has been crappy, we decided to go to Klee’s. This is a bar. A good bar, but a bar none the less, and did not qualify as our “nice” dinner of the week. The food is average at best, but the prices are at least fair. We called ahead to ensure they could get the Phillies game. When we arrived, there were empty tables in the larger than average dining room. We were a party of 6, so there were no available tables for us because of the way tables were seated. There were tables available upstairs, but the atmosphere downstairs is the only reason we dine here. We were told it would be a 10-15 minute wait for a table downstairs, which was acceptable to us.
Being the control freak that I am, I examined the dining room and identified the only possible seating option for us. There was an empty 4 top next to another 4 top where 3 ladies were finishing their meals. There were no other options in the 15 minute time period. Various parties came in and were seated. The empty 4 top remained empty. Perfect. The ladies had just paid and the table was about to be cleared. Then it happened. A party of four entered and was seated at the empty table that clearly should have been reserved for us. There were 3 other empty tables to seat them that would in no way accommodate our party.
I approached the hostess. “What table do you have in mind for us?” I asked. “Whatever opens up,” she replied. “Well those two tables would have been the only option,” I point out. “There was no reason to seat those people there when we have been waiting 20 minutes already,” I added. “You could have been seated upstairs if you were in a hurry to sit,” she snarled as she stormed away. We walk out.
Now it is pouring rain and we have no options for viewing a Phillies game, 4 hungry children, and the husband is not interested in driving to Lavallette. To Bum Rogers we go…………
It may be hard to make out this room, so let me paint you a picture………… Empty room, except for the local yokle blue hairs. Although we had NO shot of seeing a Phillies game, since the Mets game was on at the bar, we had no shot of watching anything in the dining room (See exhibit A, blacked out TV to left). The children were thrilled to be here, so that made things more pleasant, and dinner for 6 was only $149, so things could have been worst. What came across loud and clear was that seasonal businesses ( and this is an all year spot, actually) have no commitment to quality.
1. They had no salad for my 8 year old. The waitress explained that they are not busy enough to carry…… wait for it…….lettuce.
2. We felt like we were in Kitchen Nightmares as a kitchen worker (chef would be too strong a title) exclaimed “I don’t give a fuck about any of this shit.”
3. Buffalo wings look like this:
Why yes, they did call them Buffalo Wings
4. The Calamari looked like this:
Actually doesn’t look awful, and didn’t taste awful, but damn it; can anyone work a fryer?
5. Clams are the size of my fist.
Picture is dark, but I know you feel me……
6. Mussels (not shown) tasted fishy and my 8 year old refused to eat them. (She was 0 for 2).
7. Best thing on the menu is the lobster, oh and it’s giant at 1 lb!
I will not speak of the soggy corn that sat in a pot of water for 8 hours.
Our beers went empty for the entire meal because our server was texting and never returned to the table. It is what it is, but last night I was pissed.
Give me your suggestions for Philadelphia quality beach restaurants. I’m willing and eager to try! This may be my summer’s mission!











Bread Heads
Random Dining Room



